Critically evaluating resources is an important piece of the research process. In order to effectively evaluate articles, it is useful to distinguish scholarly journals from non-scholarly journals.
Scholarly Journals |
Popular Magazines |
|
Have a serious look. |
Have a slick look. |
|
Always cite their sources with footnotes or bibliography. |
Sometimes sources are cited, but usually not. |
|
Written by a scholar or researcher in the field. |
Generally written by a member of the magazine's staff or a free lance writer. |
|
Written for an audience with background in the field. |
Covers general interests and appeals to a broad audience. |
|
Much of the research done is original. |
Information is second or third hand. |
|
Includes few advertisements. |
Includes many advertisements. |
|
Many of these journals are published by |
Published by commercial presses. |
| EXAMPLES: Journal of Marriage and Family American Economic Review Modern Fiction Studies |
EXAMPLES: Time People Weekly Sports Illustrated |
Adapted from:
Engle, Michael. Distinguishing scholarly journals from other periodicals.
Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Library. Retrieved on March 25, 2003, from the World Wide Web:
http://www.library.cornell.edu/okuref/research/skill20.html
Winston Salem State University Library. Library guides - distinguishing between scholarly journals
and other periodicals. Winston-Salem, NC: Winston-Salem University. Retrieved March 25, 2003, from the
World Wide Web: http://www.wssu.edu/library/guides/popschol.asp